Compare military bases / Carlisle Barracks → Fort Benning
Carlisle → Benning
Compare Carlisle Barracks and Fort Benning
Will my BAH (Basic Allowance for Housing) go up or down if I move from Carlisle Barracks to Fort Benning?
This calculator uses 2026 DTMO (Defense Travel Management Office) rates for selected pay grade and dependent status.
Monthly BAH at E-5 pay grade without dependents.
- Carlisle Barracks
- $1,617
- Fort Benning
- $1,482
- Lower BAH at Fort Benning
BAH minus HUD 2-bedroom rent for the ZIP nearest each base.
- Carlisle Barracks
- +$127/mo
- Fort Benning
- +$482/mo
Housing just outside the gate: Carlisle vs Columbus
Rents shown on table are the 40th-percentile for 2 and 3 bedroom figures for the residential ZIP code nearest the base.
| Carlisle Barracks Carlisle 17015 | Fort Benning Columbus 31903 | |
|---|---|---|
| Median home value (city) | $224,100 | $193,900 |
| Median gross rent (city) | $1,094/mo | $1,106 |
| HUD ZIP 2-BR rent | $1,490/mo | $1,000 |
| HUD ZIP 3-BR rent | $1,920/mo | $1,320 |
| HUD metro 2-BR rent (wider area) | $1,493/mo | $1,088 |
| E-5 without dependents minus 2-BR | +$127/mo | +$482/mo |
| E-5 with dependents minus 3-BR | +$156/mo | +$396/mo |
E-5 without dependents vs a HUD 2-bedroom is +$127/mo at Carlisle Barracks vs +$482/mo at Fort Benning. E-5 with dependents vs a 3-bedroom is +$156/mo vs +$396/mo.
Host-state comparison: Pennsylvania vs. Georgia
| Pennsylvania | Georgia | |
|---|---|---|
| Sales tax | 6.34% | 7.49% |
| Property tax | 1.26% | 0.79% |
| Personal property tax | No | No |
| Top state income tax | 3.07% | 5.19% |
| Median home value | $288,697 | $335,116 |
| Branch | Army | Army |
| HUD 2-BR FMR | $1,493 | $1,088 |
| Climate high/low | 64° / 45°F | 70° / 49°F |
| Annual precip | 44.2 in | 51.9 in |
| Nearby city | Carlisle | Columbus |
| Host state | Pennsylvania | Georgia |
Click here for the full state comparison: Pennsylvania → Georgia
PCS checklist for Fort Benning
- Update DEERS. BAH at Fort Benning uses MHA GA075 (ZIP 31905).
- Look up your exact rate on the DTMO BAH lookup.
- HUD 2-bedroom FMR near Fort Benning is $1,088/mo. On-base housing is separate.
- New Georgia residents typically have 30 days for a license and 30 days to title a car.
- Reporting: Fort Benning.
Biggest differences
- E-5 with-dependents BAH is lower at Fort Benning ($1,716 vs $2,076).
- Median owner-occupied home value in the off-base city is $193,900 in Columbus vs $224,100 in Carlisle (Census ACS 5-year, 2020–2024).
- HUD ZIP 2-bedroom rent just outside the gate is $1,000 in 31903 vs $1,490 in 17015.
- Host-state wage tax is Flat 3.07% (local earned-income tax extra) in Pennsylvania vs Top listed rate 5.19% in Georgia (military pay usually follows legal residence, not the duty station).
- Combined sales tax averages 7.49% in Georgia vs 6.34% in Pennsylvania.
Common questions
Can I PCS from Carlisle Barracks to Fort Benning?
This pair is listed because the installations share a tenant service (Army). Your actual orders depend on your MOS/AFSC/rating and the gaining unit.
How does BAH change from Carlisle Barracks to Fort Benning?
DTMO CY2026 with- and without-dependents rates for every pay grade are in the BAH table on this page. E-5 with dependents: $2,076 vs $1,716; without dependents: $1,617 vs $1,482.
What is local rent like near Fort Benning?
HUD FY2026 Small Area FMR for ZIP 31903 (Columbus) is $1,000/mo for a 2-bedroom and $1,320/mo for a 3-bedroom. The wider metro 2-BR FMR is $1,088/mo.
What do homes cost in Carlisle vs Columbus?
Census ACS 5-year (2020–2024) median value of owner-occupied homes is $224,100 in Carlisle borough, Pennsylvania vs $193,900 in Columbus city, Georgia. Median gross rent in those cities is $1,094 vs $1,106. These are city medians (owners’ reported values), not last month’s sale prices.
Will BAH cover off-base rent if I PCS from Carlisle Barracks to Fort Benning?
E-5 without dependents minus a HUD 2-bedroom is +$127/mo at Carlisle Barracks vs +$482/mo at Fort Benning. E-5 with dependents minus a 3-bedroom is +$156/mo vs +$396/mo. Use the calculator for other pay grades. Actual listings vary; BAH is untaxed housing pay, not a rent cap.
Does my state income tax change if I PCS from Carlisle Barracks to Fort Benning?
Usually not just because the duty station changes. Military pay generally follows legal residence under the Servicemembers Civil Relief Act; spouses may have similar protection. Pennsylvania: Flat 3.07% (local earned-income tax extra). Georgia: Top listed rate 5.19%. BAH is not taxed. Sales tax and titling a car follow the state you live in.
Related PCS
Fort Benning → Carlisle Barracks · Fort Benning → Fort Stewart
Your PCS
Only destinations that share a service with the origin are listed.
Sources
Housing figures below are for the installation (MHA, HUD rent, climate). Host-state tax rates in the snapshot above BAH are statewide averages — not a tax return. County add-ons can differ, and wage tax on military pay follows legal residence, not the duty station.
- BAH (with and without dependents). DTMO CY2026 BAH tables for Carlisle Barracks (PA247); Fort Benning (GA075). Confirm current rates on the DTMO BAH lookup.
- 2-bedroom Fair Market Rent. HUD FY2026 FMR — Cumberland County $1,493; Chattahoochee County $1,088.
- Off-base ZIP rent (HUD Small Area FMR). FY2026 ZIP 2- and 3-bedroom 40th-percentile rents from the HUD Small Area FMR tables: 17015 (Carlisle) $1,490 / $1,920; 31903 (Columbus) $1,000 / $1,320.
- Off-base city home value and rent. U.S. Census Bureau American Community Survey 5-year 2020–2024 tables B25077 (median value of owner-occupied homes) and B25064 (median gross rent) for Carlisle borough, Pennsylvania ($224,100, $1,094/mo) and Columbus city, Georgia ($193,900, $1,106/mo). Owner-reported values, not transaction prices.
- Climate normals (1991–2020). NOAA NCEI U.S. Climate Normals — Harrisburg Intl (NWS) (USW00014711); Columbus Metro (NWS) (USW00013891).
- Host-state wage tax. Statewide listed rates for Pennsylvania and Georgia from the Tax Foundation 2026 individual income-tax tables. On this page they describe the host state, not automatically the tax on a military LES (legal residence can stay put). BAH is untaxed.
- Combined sales tax near the installation. Tax Foundation January 2026 state-and-local sales-tax averages for Pennsylvania and Georgia. Used as an off-base shopping stand-in; city and county add-ons vary.
- Effective property tax if you buy off-base. Tax Foundation 2026 property taxes by state for Pennsylvania and Georgia. On-base housing is not in this figure.
- Vehicle title tax and new-resident clocks. Pennsylvania motor-vehicle agency (license 60 days, title 20 days; title tax 6.00%); Georgia motor-vehicle agency (license 30 days, title 30 days; title tax 7.00%). These are host-state motor-vehicle rules, not BAH.
- Vehicle personal-property tax on the host-state snapshot. WalletHub 2026 vehicle property-tax table for Pennsylvania and Georgia. This is a statewide car-tax flag, not real-estate tax and not BAH.
- Statewide median home value on the host-state snapshot. Experian / Zillow March 2026 state medians for Pennsylvania and Georgia. Backdrop for off-base purchase prices; on-base housing and BAH are separate.